Smart Phones for Smart Students Part III: Verizon Wireless
It’s that time again – time for me to show you the best smartphones for a specific carrier. Today’s carrier is…Verizon Wireless. I know a lot of people who have Verizon because they offer great coverage in many areas. I won’t get it because most of my friends are on Cingular and I can talk for free to them. Also, I won’t pay $60 to Verizon for just 450 minutes of service. All complaining aside, though, I would like to show you three powerful phones from a very powerful provider: the Samsung SCH-i730, the Verizon Wireless XV6700, and the Palm Treo 700wx.
Samsung SCH-i730: the Samsung SCH-i730 has a distinct style because its QWERTY keyboard slides out from the bottom, not the side (like the MDA or the 8525). The buttons on the QWERTY are small and raised, so they’re a bit easier to hit, even for people with larger thumbs. Some pros of this phone are:
a. Windows Mobile 2003 Pocket PC Phone Edition.
b. Nice interface
c. Built in Wi-Fi
d. EV-DO support
e. Bluetooth
f. SD card slot
g. Dual speakers
h. Speakerphone
The cons, though, are BIG:
a. NO CAMERA…wtf?
b. WiFi drains the battery big time
c. WiFi and phone can’t be used at the same time
d. Phone can’t be used as a modem
e. Talk time/standby time is weak – 150 minutes talk, 130 hours standby.
First of all, a phone without a camera? Are we living in the dark ages? Secondly, other phones have been able to use the Wifi as well as the phone at the same time, so what held Samsung back? So far, I’m not liking this device at all. I don’t know much about the call quality, so if someone could help me out with this, that’d be great.
Verizon Wireless XV6700: the Verizon Wireless XV6700 is styled like the Cingular 8525 and T-Mobile MDA, with its slide-out QWERTY keyboard and brick-like shape, although, this phone has an external antenna, which in my opinion is very unsightly and could jab you in the side if you bend the wrong way. The Pros:
a. Windows Mobile 5.0
b. Large screen
c. Rubbery texture for easier gripping
d. WiFi
e. Bluetooth (which can be used for file transfers with a PC, not just for accessories and headsets)
f. 1.3 MP camera/camcorder w/flash
g. Windows Media Player 10
h. 4 hour talk time
The cons:
a. Big size
b. WiFi and phone can’t work at same time (although this can be tweaked with a registry editor)
c. Poor call quality (echo-y on the other end)
If it weren’t for the call quality, I’d say this phone was a strong contender. Let’s see what the Treo has to offer.
Palm Treo 700wx: The Palm Treo 700wx is a spiffy little device. It has 64mb of RAM and runs Windows Mobile 5.0 Pocket PC Phone Edition. The Treo has a full QWERTY keyboard, but it’s a bit small for medium to larger thumbs. The pros include:
a. More memory = faster performace
b. Touch screen
c. BroadbandAccess Connect
d. Bluetooth
e. Speakerphone
f. Wireless sync
g. 1.3 MP camera
h. Windows Media Player 10
i. Backlit QWERTY keyboard
j. SD slot
k. Voice activation
l. Use as modem via USB cable included
m. Good call quality on both ends
The cons:
a. Keyboard is a tad small
b. Resolution is weak at 240 x 240
c. No WiFi
The Treo is probably the best choice of the three. Verizon doesn’t offer a “wide” selection of smartphones the way other providers do, but what they have is ok. The XV6700 and the Treo both have decent talk times and standby times – about 100 minutes more to talk for the 6700 and 150 minutes more to talk for the Treo, and about and 170 hours more standby for the 6700 and 200 hours more for the Treo. Both the 6700 or the Treo are good choices (watch out for the 6700’s call quality), but stay away from the Samsung for its lack of a camera, draining WiFi and weak battery life.
